1. Potthast Bros.,
Inc., patented the slogan “The True Antiques of Tomorrow” (no.
13082) on March 10, 1931. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts:
Inside Secrets of Selecting Furniture Correctly,” 1935, p. 21; collection
of author.
2. Interest in preindustrial craft methods and indigenous
styles was at the core of the arts and crafts movement and of the Potthasts’
philosophy. Several prominent craftsmen, including L. & J. G. Stickley,
made reproductions of antique furniture before turning to the Mission style.
See Wendy Kaplan, “The Art That Is Life”: The Arts & Crafts
Movement in America, 1875–1920 (Boston: Museum of Fine Arts, Boston,
1987), for more on the relationship between the arts and crafts movement
and the colonial revival. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts,”
p. 21. Although the Potthast brothers married other German-Americans and
maintained social connections within Baltimore’s large German-born
population, the furniture produced and sold by their firm was thoroughly
American in design. William B. Rhoads, “The Colonial Revival and the
Americanization of Immigrants,” in The Colonial Revival in America,
edited by Alan Axelrod (New York: W. W. Norton, 1985). Kenneth L. Ames,
“Introduction,” in ibid., pp. 13–14.
3. Ames, “Introduction,” pp. 13–14. For more
on Hagen, see Deborah Dependall Waters, “Is It Phyfe?” in American
Furniture, edited by Luke Beckerdite (Hanover, N.H.: University Press
of New England for the Chipstone Foundation, 1996), pp. 63–81.
4. Letterbook 1: 1908–9, letterbook 2: 1914–17,
letterbook 3: 1919, letterbook 4: 1920–21, letterbook 5: 1926–32,
ms2183, library collection, Maryland Historical Society, Baltimore. Additional
correspondence is in ms 2659. Harry B. Leopold (1891–1977) worked as
a news photographer for the Baltimore Sun and the now defunct
News American. He also operated a commercial photography business. Leopold’s
work illustrates many Baltimore buildings and businesses. His obituary was
published in the July 22, 1977, issue of the Baltimore Sun. Sample
book of photographs, Potthast family collection.
5. One brochure titled “Replicas from Collectors’
Antiques” (ca. 1930) serves as a virtual bibliography for the firm’s
sales literature. It cites Thomas Chippendale’s The Gentleman and
Cabinet-Maker’s Director (1754), George Hepplewhite’s The
Cabinet-Maker and Upholsterer’s Guide (1788), Thomas Sheraton’s
The Cabinet-Maker & Upholsterer’s Drawing Book (1793), and
the Society of Upholsterer’s The London Cabinet-Maker’s Book
of Prices (1788). This brochure also states that “[in addition
to museums] there is . . . another genuine source of much reliable information
that is available through distinguished authorities—writers of furniture
history with many illustrations in their books.”
6. Additional references include “Sheraton, 1751–1806,”
and “Hepplewhite, 1780 a.d.” Robert and Elizabeth Shackleton,
The Quest of the Colonial, 3d ed. (1906; reprint ed., New York: Century
Co., 1921).
7. Jane S. Smith, Elsie de Wolfe: A Life in the High
Style (New York: Atheneum, 1982). Elsie de Wolfe, The House in Good
Taste (New York: Century Co., 1915), pp. 260–61.
8. Letterbook, 1907, p. 305, Potthast family collection.
Mrs. Barbara White interviews with the author, Baltimore, Maryland, spring
1999. Mrs. White was the granddaughter-in-law of C. Wilbur and Edith Miller.
No records supporting a business relationship between Edmunds and de Wolfe
have surfaced, but it is possible that she was involved in the design of
the Millers’ chairs. This important suite of furniture represents the
zenith of the colonial revival style and some of the finest custom designs
of Potthast Bros., Inc.
9. Gregory R. Weidman, Furniture in Maryland, 1740–1940:
The Collection of the Maryland Historical Society (Baltimore: Maryland
Historical Society, 1984), pp. 210, 213.
10. Das Neue Baltimore, translated by Sister Benedicta,
SSND (Baltimore: German Publishing Company, 1905), p. 174. This publication
highlighted German-American businesses in Baltimore after the 1904 fire that
destroyed seventy city blocks, more than fifteen hundred buildings, and twenty-five
hundred businesses. For details of the fire, see Robert J. Brugger, Maryland:
A Middle Temperament 1634–1980 (Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University
Press, 1988), p. 416.
11. For more on William Camp, see Gregory R. Weidman, “The
Furniture of Classical Maryland,” in Classical Maryland, 1815–1845:
Fine and Decorative Arts from the Golden Age (Baltimore: Maryland Historical
Society, 1993). The Camp chest sold at Richard Opfer Auctioneers, Timonium,
Maryland, in July 1994. Potthast Bros., Inc., to Mrs. Geo. H. Hills, Fall
River, Massachusetts, May 23, 1907, letterbook, 1907.
12. Weidman, Furniture in Maryland, p. 235.
13. O. A. Kirkland Auctioneer, Catalogue of the Celebrated
Dr. William H. Crim Collection of Genuine Antiques, Baltimore, April
22–May 2, 1903. Potthast, Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts,”
illustration, p. 21.
14. Kirkland Auctioneer, Crim Collection, lot. 774.
15. Report of the Maryland Commission to the Jamestown
Ter-Centennial Exposition (Baltimore, Md.: Williams & Co., 1908).
Built in 1801, Homewood is owned by Johns Hopkins University and has been
open to the public as a historic house museum since 1987. The Maryland Building
from the 1907 Jamestown Exposition survives along with twelve of the original
twenty-one state buildings. All are currently used as admirals’ housing
on the Norfolk Naval Base. C. F. Meislahn & Co. (w. 1887–1941)
of Baltimore produced the interiors of the Maryland Building. The firm had
made architectural models and done work for the 1904 restoration of the
senate chamber in the Maryland State House in Annapolis in an effort to
return the room to its Revolutionary era appearance. Report of the Maryland
Commission. Loan inventory, letterbook, 1907.
16. Report of the Maryland Commission, pp. 38–42.
17. Letterbook, 1907.
18. Potthast Bros., Inc., to Tiffany Studios, New York,
October 5, 8, and 19, 1907, letterbook, 1907.
19. Baltimore City Directories, 1928 and 1930.
20. Potthast Bros., Inc., “The ‘Antiques of Tomorrow’
Produced by Potthast Bros. Inc.,” Baltimore Magazine, September
1938, pp. 21–23. Theodore J. Potthast, Jr., and Marie Corcoran Potthast,
“Potthast Bros., Inc.: A Brief History,” unpublished manuscript,
1990, n.p. Other Potthast genealogical information was derived from company
letterheads, labeled family photographs, and interviews with various family
members.
21. Potthast and Potthast, “Potthast Bros., Inc.”
22. Fred Judd, “The Wonderful Potthast Past,”
Baltimore Evening Sun, October 3, 1985.
23. Lucien Rhodes, “Handmade Furniture: Potthast Closes
after 85 years,” Baltimore Sun, February 3, 1975. Judd, “The Wonderful
Potthast Past.”
24. American Art Association, Colonial Furniture: The
Superb Collection of the Late Howard Reifsnyder, New York, April 24–27,
1929. American Art Association, Colonial Furniture, Silver, and Decorations:
The Collection of the late Philip Flayderman, New York, January 2–4,
1930.
25. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Replicas from Collectors’
Antiques,” ca. 1930.
26. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Reproductions That Are
An Investment,” ca. 1930, p. 4.
27. Edgar G. Miller, Jr., American Antique Furniture:
A Book for Amateurs (Baltimore, Md.: Lord Baltimore Press, 1937). The
Potthasts’ shop copy of this book is in a private collection.
28. Susan G. Tripp, “Homewood in Baltimore, Maryland,”
Antiques 133, no. 1 (January 1980): 248–57. Examples of similar
chairs, or possibly others from this set, were in the Crim sale. This may
have given the Potthast craftsmen additional exposure to this form.
29. Mrs. Muth was a descendent of Charles Carroll of Homewood.
Theodore J. Potthast interview with the author, summer 1995, Baltimore,
Maryland. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts:,” p. 18.
30. Potthast Letterbooks, passim.
31. Theodore J. Potthast interview with the author, summer
1995, Baltimore, Maryland. Potthast Bros., Inc., “The ‘Antiques
of Tomorrow,’” pp. 2–4.
32. Potthast Bros., Inc., “The Metropolitan Museum,”
ca. 1930. The Metropolitan Museum of Art deaccessioned their sideboard at
Christie’s, Important American Furniture, Silver, Folk Art, and
Decorative Art, New York, June 19, 1996, lot 179. For more on this sale,
see Maine Antique Digest, August 1996, 20-E. The opening of the American
Wing in the Metropolitan Museum of Art stimulated interest in antique furniture
and fueled the demand for reproductions. The Potthasts’ library includes
a copy of R. T. H. Halsey and Charles Over Cornelius’s Handbook
of the American Wing (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1924). In
1936, the price of the “Metropolitan” sideboard was $415. Potthast
Bros., Inc., “44th Anniversary—Expansion Sale.”
33. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Mount Vernon,” ca.
1930. In 1936 the price of the “Mount Vernon” sideboard was $240.
Potthast Bros., Inc., “44th Anniversary—Expansion Sale.”
34. Potthast Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts.”
Weidman, Furniture in Maryland, pp. 14, 213–14, nos. 221, 252.
35. Ibid.
36. Weidman, Furniture in Maryland, pp. 259–60.
Potthast Bros., Inc., “Interesting Facts,” p. 2.
37. Theodore J. Potthast interview with the author, summer
1995, Baltimore, Md.
38. The Maryland Historical Society purchased a Potthast
card table (67.57.11) in 1967, probably because it belonged to H. L. Mencken
(1880–1956)—a journalist and essayist known as the “Sage
of Baltimore.” For more on the card table, see Weidman, Furniture
in Maryland, p. 258. The society’s collection of Potthast furniture
also includes a “Crim” chair (57.3.6) and a “Key” chair
(57.3.4). Both were added to the collection in 1957, while the Potthasts
were still in business. Early on, the society recognized the significance
of Dr. Crim’s collection and sale and the importance of the Potthasts’
decision to reproduce objects owned by him. For more on the sideboard, dining
table, card table and chairs, see acc. 79.75.1–5, Maryland Historical
Society. |