1. Alice Winchester to Mrs. Sherman, September 11, 1940; Herbert O. Brigham
(librarian of the Newport Historical Society [hereafter cited NHS]) to
Alice Winchester, September 30, 1940; and Alice Winchester to Herbert
O. Brigham, October 15, 1940, Baker genealogy file, NHS. The author thanks
Ron Potvin for sharing this story and the pertinent references. George
H. Richardson (18381916) records the brief entry "Benj Baker,
at the Point" in his list of "Furniture Makers or Cabinet Makers"
within his larger manuscript, "Occupations: Craftsmen in Newport,
And other Information about the Town's Inhabitants," G.H.R. scrapbook
no. 982, p. 29, NHS. Baker is mentioned as a Newport cabinetmaker in Ethel
Hall Bjerkoe, The Cabinetmakers of America (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday,
1957), p. 36. Baker was described as a "Joiner" in an October
9, 1777, account in Dr. William Hunter's Physician's Book (453), p. 25,
NHS.
2. Jeanne Vibert Sloane, "John Cahoone and the Newport Furniture
Industry," in New England Furniture: Essays in Memory of Benno M.
Forman (Boston: Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities,
1987), pp. 88122. Martha H. Willoughby, "The Accounts of Job
Townsend, Jr.," in American Furniture, edited by Luke Beckerdite
(Hanover, N.H.: University Press of New England for the Chipstone Foundation,
1999), pp. 10961.
3. Willoughby, "The Accounts of Job Townsend, Jr.," p. 119,
table 3. The figures of furniture exported from Rhode Island as recorded
in the "Imports and Exports (America) Ledger, 17681774"
(Public Records Office, Kew, England) are calculated in Anne Rogers Haley,
"Whither Bound? Exports of Rhode Island Furniture on the Eve of the
American War of Independence, 17681772" (manuscript), p. 6.
I am grateful to Anne Rogers Haley for this information.
4. Wendy A. Cooper, In Praise of America: American Decorative Arts, 16501830
(Washington, D.C.: National Gallery of Art, 1980), p. 27. Charles J. Burns,
"The Newport Legacy of Miss Doris Duke: A History of the Newport
Restoration Foundation and a Catalogue of Its Collection at the Samuel
Whitehorne Museum" (master's thesis, Trinity College, 1995), cat.
no. 33. Parke-Bernet Galleries, Important 18th Century American Furniture
and Decorations, New York, May 22, 1971, lot 199. The high chest is also
illustrated on the cover of this catalogue.
5. Cooper, In Praise of America, pp. 2728. Cooper suggests that
Baker may have had a hand in making the high chest; however, she questions
the location of the signature. Michael Moses, Master Craftsmen of Newport:
The Townsends and Goddards (Tenafly, N.J.: MMI Americana Press, 1984),
p. 194. At the end of his chapter on the work of John Townsend, Moses
includes detailed photographs of the high chest illustrated in fig. 1
in comparison to similar views of two other high chests, one made by John
Townsend and another attributed to him. Jeanne Vibert Sloane attributes
the high chest illustrated in fig. 1 to Baker ("John Cahoone,"
p. 92 and fig. 1). In his master's thesis on the Doris Duke collection,
Charles Burns questions the traditional attribution of the high chest
to John Goddard, noting the formal similarities to John Townsend's work.
He stops short of attributing the object to Townsend, however, citing
the presence of the Baker signature and the collaboration between the
two cabinetmakers noted in the Baker account book (Burns, "The Newport
Legacy of Miss Doris Duke," cat. no. 33). Similarly, Gerald W. R.
Ward suggests that both Townsend and Baker may have collaborated on the
chest in "‘America's Contribution to Craftsmanship': The Exaltation
and Interpretation of Newport Furniture," in American Furniture,
edited by Luke Beckerdite (Hanover, N.H.: University Press of New England
for the Chipstone Foundation, 1999), p. 233, fig. 6. In addition to the
high chest signed and dated by John Townsend, the following pieces have
carved shells with fleur-de-lis motifs: a high chest at the Museum of
Fine Arts, Boston; a signed and dated document chest in the collection
of the Chipstone Foundation; and a three-shell bureau in the Diplomatic
Reception Rooms, U.S. Department of State. Willoughby, "The Accounts
of Job Townsend, Jr.," p. 115.
6. Townsend's ownership of property on the Point in Newport is discussed
in Moses, Master Craftsmen, pp. 65, 67.
7. Furniture maker and author Jeffrey Greene discovered the signature in
2001. Data Research Report, Preservation Society of Newport County (PSNC.1707).
The author thanks John Bartosh for assisting in the examination of the
dressing table at Hunter House and Rebecca Kelly for providing information
from the object file.
8. The dressing table is illustrated in Ralph E. Carpenter Jr., The Arts
and Crafts of Newport, Rhode Island, 16401820 (Newport, R.I.: The
Preservation Society of Newport County, 1954), cat. no. 61. It was later
purchased by the Preservation Society from its owner, Mrs. Philip G. Birckhead.
She was a descendant of William Hunter, Esq., the owner of the house on
Washington Street in Newport where the object is now displayed
9. Philip Zea and Robert C. Cheney, Clock Making in New England, 17251825:
An Interpretation of the Old Sturbridge Village Collection (Sturbridge,
Mass.: Old Sturbridge Village, 1992), pp. 1415, 163. The clock descended
in the family of its original owner, Abraham Brown of Tiverton, Rhode
Island. The clock is also discussed in Richard Champlin, "Thomas
Claggett: Silversmith, Swordsman, Clockmaker," Newport History 49,
no. 163 (summer 1976): 6062. Baker's accounts with Claggett are
mentioned briefly in Richard L. Champlin, "William Claggett and His
Clockmaking Family," Newport History 47, no. 155 (summer 1974): 182.
10. Sloane, "John Cahoone," p. 88.
11. Death notice for Benjamin Baker, Rhode-Island Republican (Newport),
January 9, 1822. The marriage of Benjamin Baker and Martha Simpson at
the Second Congregational Church in Newport on January 28, 1759, is recorded
in James N. Arnold, Vital Records of Rhode Island, 16361850, 21
vols. (Providence, R.I.: Narragansett Historical Publishing Company, 1896),
8: 458. James Easton et al. v. Benjamin Baker, Newport County Court of
Common Pleas, May term 1764, case 214, Record Book G, pp. 271, 305. The
case was appealed to the Newport County Supreme Court and heard during
the May term 1765, Record Book E, p. 276. The case was appealed to "the
King in Council in Great Britain" and "refused by the Court,
for that it doth not appear to them that the Title of the Land is in dispute
but the Rent only." A deed in the Newport City Hall records the sale
of lot 93, Second Division, on Easton's Point to Benjamin Baker, "Cabinet
Maker" of Newport, on June 10, 1800 (Proprietors of Easton's Point
to Benjamin Baker, May 10, 1800, Newport Land Evidence, vol. 12, p. 102).
Baker bequeathed this lot on Elm Street to his daughter Ellenor, wife
of Henry Goddard (Will of Benjamin Baker, December 5, 1821, Newport Probate
Records, vol. 11, p. 117). Goddard was the executor of Baker's estate.
The latter's heirs sold this land to Francis L. Tripp (Susan Howard et
al. to Francis L. Tripp, April 10, 1846, Newport Land Evidence, vol. 26,
pp. 28384). The "Goddard" chair passed down in the family
of Benjamin Baker's daughter Susan (m. Henry Howland). Likewise, the inventory
of Baker's son William lists a large percentage of furniture that may
give further insight into Baker's production: "One Mahogany Desk
$20. Two Mahogany Card Tables $20. One Dining Table $4 / Eight Chairs
Hair Bottoms $12. One large looking glass $10. One small ditto $5 / Two
Tables and one Stand $7. Eleven Chairs $6 . . . / . . . One Table and
One Chest $1.50 / One Small Writing Desk $4. Three Bedsteads and Bedding
$175" (Inventory of William H. Baker, December 15, 1803, Newport
Probate Records, vol. 4, p. 114).
12. Thomas Hornsby, "Newport, Past and Present," Newport Daily
Advertiser, December 8, 1849, as quoted in Sloane, "John Cahoone,"
p. 92. This quote is repeated in George Champlin Mason, Reminiscences
of Newport (Newport: Charles E. Hammett Jr., 1894), p. 49; and Carpenter,
The Arts and Crafts of Newport, p. 9. Sloane, p. 104, argues that Newport
cabinetmakers commonly exported red cedar desks, whereas there is little
evidence for this type of desk being used locally. Baker also sold a "Redseder
Desk" to William Wever in 1775. A May 18, 1785, receipt with Baker's
signature and a credit for repairing a mahogany bedstead for Joseph Lopez
is in the Aaron Lopez Papers, box 168, folder 6, NHS.
13. Baker's whereabouts during the Revolution are not recorded in his
account book. A cryptic note in the Rhode Island State Archives records:
"John Mowry bill for food and drink delivered to Benjamin Baker by
order of John Northup and B Gardner," December session 1776, C#0292General
Treasurer: Accounts AllowedRhode Island State Archives. A letter
written to His Excellency the Commander and Chief at Newport included
Benjamin Baker among a list of subscribers who, "being Absent from
our Familiys [sic] at the Time of the Emancipation of Newport," sought
admittance to the city (Rhode Island State Archives, List of Persons Permitted
to Reside in the State, December 2, 1779, Council of WarLetters
and Accounts, vol. 1, p. 128). Baker's association with Newport joiner
Thomas Atwood is indicated by an October 1761 account entry for one barrel
of flour, £30.8, that the former gave the latter. Sampson Shearman v.
Thomas Atwood, Newport County Court of Common Pleas, November term 1762,
case 259. Death notice for Benjamin Baker: "died, In this town, on
Sunday last, Mr. Benjamin Baker, aged 87. Funeral from his late dwelling,
at the house of the widow Helme, near the North Battery, this afternoon,
at 2 o'clock. Relations and friends are invited to attend without further
notice." Another death notice for Baker appeared in the Newport Mercury,
Saturday, January 12, 1822, vol. 61, no. 3118. The death of his wife,
Martha, on December 26, 1815, at age 80, is recorded in the Rhode-Island
Republican, Newport, Wednesday, January 17, 1816, vol. 7, no. 42. |