Erik K. Gronning
Luxury of Choice: Boston's Early Baroque Seating Furniture

American Furniture 2018

Full Article
Contents
  • Figure 1
    Figure 1

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 43 1/2", W. 18 1/4", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 2
    Figure 2

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1685–1705. Maple and oak. H. 48", W. 20 1/4", D. 22". (Chipstone Foundation; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This is the first American example of a slot placed in the crest to pass through the leather upholstery.

  • Figure 3
    Figure 3

    Armchair, probably London, 1685–1700. Woods and dimensions not recorded. (Photo, Symonds Collection, Decorative Arts Photographic Collection, Winterthur Library.) The back rails of this chair have a noticeable curve or hollow.

  • Figure 4
    Figure 4

    Side chair, probably London, 1685–1700. Beech; original turkeywork upholstery. H. 48 5/8". (Courtesy, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, gift of Mrs. Winthrop Sargent in memory of her husband Jun, 17.1629.)

  • Figure 5
    Figure 5

    Side chair, probably London, 1685–1700. Woods and dimensions not recorded; original leather upholstery. (Photo, Symonds Collection, Decorative Arts Photographic Collection, Winterthur Library.) The crest and lower back rails have a noticeable curve or hollow. The turnings on the back posts closely relate to those present on group B chairs (fig. 13).

  • Figure 6
    Figure 6

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1685–1705. Maple and oak. H. 42", W. 20", D. 20 1/2". (Courtesy, Anne H. and Frederick Vogel III Collection for the Philadelphia Museum of Art, acc. no. 188-2016-8.) The gilding was added in the nineteenth century. This chair is the only example of the group with a single side stretcher.

  • Figure 7
    Figure 7

    Couch, Boston, Massachusetts, 1685–1705. Maple and oak. H. 38", W. 21 1/2", D. 84". (Courtesy, Anne H. and Frederick Vogel III Collection for the Philadelphia Museum of Art, acc. no. 188-2016-9.) This is the only ball-turned couch known, and it may have been made en suite with the side chair illustrated in fig. 6.

  • Figure 8
    Figure 8

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1685–1705. Maple and oak. H. 41 3/8", W. 19 1/2", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The back dimensions are the same as those of low-back chairs, but the orientation is vertical rather than horizontal. The nailing pattern, with brass-headed nails at the top and wrought iron tacks at the bottom, is commonly found on Cromwellian chairs.

  • Figure 9
    Figure 9

    Side chair, England, 1675–1695. Oak. H. 43", W. 21 1/2". (Courtesy, Victoria and Albert Museum, London, W.29-1928.) The feet are missing.

  • Figure 10
    Figure 10

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1685–1705. Maple and oak. H. 48 3/4", W. 23 1/2", D. 18". (Private collection; photo, Jim Wildeman.) The arms of this chair are carved with leafage and relate to those on contemporaneous English chairs like the one shown in fig. 12. The finials are identical to those on the side chair illustrated in fig. 8. The feet are restored.

  • Figure 11
    Figure 11

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 47 1/2", W. 23 3/4", D. 17 3/4". (Courtesy, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston; Arthur Tracy Cabot Fund, 1971.624.) The iron rods in the arms are a nineteenth-century addition, and the feet are missing but would have been like those on the side chair illustrated in fig. 16.

  • Figure 12
    Figure 12

    Armchair, probably London, 1685–1700. Woods and dimensions not recorded. (Photo, Symonds Collection, Decorative Arts Photographic Collection, Winterthur Library.)

  • Figure 13
    Figure 13

    Composite illustration showing the rear post of the
    (a) Group B armchair with foliate carved arms illustrated in fig. 11;
    (b) Group B armchair illustrated in fig 18;
    (c) Group B side chair illustrated in fig. 17;
    (d) Group B side chair illustrated in fig. 24;
    (e) Group C side chair illustrated in fig. 31;
    (f) Group D armchair illustrated in fig. 45;
    (g) Group E side chair illustrated in fig. 56;
    (h) Group F side chair illustrated in fig. 69.

  • Figure 14
    Figure 14

    Composite illustration showing the front stretchers of the
    (a) Group B armchair with foliate carved arms illustrated in fig. 11;
    (b) Group B side chair illustrated in fig. 16;
    (c) Group B side chair illustrated in fig. 23;
    (d) New York side chair illustrated in fig. 51;
    (e) Group E side chair illustrated in fig. 72.

  • Figure 15
    Figure 15

    Composite illustration showing the arm support of the
    (a) Group A armchair with foliate carved arms illustrated in fig. 10;
    (b) Group B armchair with foliate carved arms illustrated in fig. 11;
    (c) Group B armchair with scroll-carved arms illustrated in fig. 18;
    (d) Group D armchair illustrated in fig. 53;
    (e) Group E armchair illustrated in fig. 88;
    (f) Group E armchair illustrated in fig. 60;
    (g) Group F armchair illustrated in fig. 112;
    (h) Group C armchair illustrated in fig. 38 (arm scroll terminals replaced).

  • Figure 16
    Figure 16

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 46 5/8", W. 18 1/4", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This side chair has rear posts identical to those of the chairs illustrated in figs. 11, 17, 18, and 20, absent the ring and compressed ball directly below the lowermost baluster turning.

  • Figure 17
    Figure 17

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 43 3/8", W. 17 5/8", D. 14 3/8". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 18
    Figure 18

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery on the seat. H. 51 3/4", W. 24 1/2", D. 17 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Jim Wildeman.)

  • Figure 19
    Figure 19

    Detail of the stretchers and the original webbing and sackcloth under-upholstery of the armchair illustrated in fig. 18. Three webbing strips are placed front to back and are woven between the two side-to-side strips. This orientation of webbing was the standard arrangement used by Boston and New York upholsterers. Uncommon are the outer front-to-back strips angled at the same degree as the side seat rails.

  • Figure 20
    Figure 20

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 51", W. 23", D. 17". (Courtesy, Historic Huguenot Street, New Paltz, N.Y., gift of Alice Hasbrouck, 1999.7240.01.) The  arms are replaced, and the feet are missing. This chair descended through the Hardenbergh family and was owned originally by Johannes Hardenbergh (ca. 1670–1745) of Ulster County, New York.

  • Figure 21
    Figure 21

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 44 5/8", W. 18 5/8", D. 16 5/8". (Courtesy, Saint Louis Art Museum, gift of Mr. and Mrs. Edward J. Nusrala, 249:1989.) The barrel turning above the seat is scored at its widest point. The urn finials diverge from the standard “muffin” variety.

  • Figure 22
    Figure 22

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple. H. 45 5/8", W. 18 1/8", D. 15 1/4". (Courtesy, Milwaukee Art Museum, Layton Art Collection, L1982.116; photo, Richard Eells.) This chair descended in the family of artist Pieter Vanderlyn (ca. 1687–1778) of Kingston, New York. Pieter immigrated to New York City from the Netherlands in 1718. His arrival date suggests he acquired the chair from an earlier owner. The top and lower back rail have a noticeable curve or hollow.

  • Figure 23
    Figure 23

    Side chair, probably Boston, Massachusetts, 1700–1720. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 47 3/4", W. 18 1/2", D. 18 3/4". (Chipstone Foundation; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This chair’s leather trim strip was secured with brass nails along the top edge and wrought iron tacks along the lower edge.

  • Figure 24
    Figure 24

    Side chair, probably Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 43 5/8", W. 17 5/8", D. 14 3/4". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 25
    Figure 25

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 48 1/4", W. 17 3/8", D. 12 7/8". (Private collection; photo, Nathan Liverant and Son.) This is the only group B side chair with a carved crest rail and stretcher.

  • Figure 26
    Figure 26

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 46 3/4", W. 19", D. 17 3/8". (Private collection; photo, Scottish Rite Masonic Museum and Library.)

  • Figure 27
    Figure 27

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1695–1705. Woods and dimensions not recorded. (Esther Singleton, The Furniture of Our Forefathers [New York: Doubleday, Page and Company, 1906], p. 183.)

  • Figure 28
    Figure 28

    Armchair, London, 1695–1705. Beech; original Japanned decoration. H. 51 3/4", W. 23 3/8", D. 17". (Private collection; photo, Bill Russell.) This armchair’s seat would have been caned. It represents the first use of “banisters” as back support in English seating furniture. The ball feet are replaced.

  • Figure 29
    Figure 29

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1700–1715. Maple. H. 53 3/4", W. 23 7/8", D. 16 3/8". (Courtesy, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, gift of Mrs. Charles L. Bybee, 1980.379.) The complex, asymmetrically turned arm supports are essentially half of a Boston gateleg leg turning. This chair was given to Rev. John Chester (1785–1829) of Albany,  New York, by one of his parishioners.

  • Figure 30
    Figure 30

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1700–1715. Maple and oak. H. 46 3/4", W. 18 1/4", D. 14 3/4". (Courtesy, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, gift of Mr. and Mrs. Miodrag R. Blagojevich, 1976-430.)

  • Figure 31
    Figure 31

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1700–1715. Maple and oak. H. 48", W. 18", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Jim Wildeman.)

  • Figure 32
    Figure 32

    Armchair, New York City, 1695–1715. Maple with oak and hickory. H. 47 1/2", W. 25 1/2", D. 27". (Courtesy, Historic Hudson Valley, Tarrytown, New York.) The feet and the finials are incorrectly restored.

  • Figure 33
    Figure 33

    Armchair, New York, 1700–1740. Maple. H. 50 1/2". (Courtesy, Sotheby’s Inc.) The feet are replacements.

  • Figure 34
    Figure 34

    Armchair, New York City, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 52", W. 24 3/4", D. 17 1/2". (Chipstone Foundation; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The urn and baluster turned arm supports are nearly identical to those on the rear posts of the armchair illustrated in fig. 28.

  • Figure 35
    Figure 35

    Side chair, New York City, 1695–1710. Maple and oak. H. 46 3/4", W. 18 1/4", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 36
    Figure 36

    Side chair, probably Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 45 1/2", W. 18", D. 15". (Courtesy, Greene County [New York] Historical Society.) This chair descended through the Bronck family of Coxsackie, New York, and was discovered with remnants of the original Russia leather upholstery on the back.

  • Figure 37
    Figure 37

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. Dimensions not recorded. (Courtesy, Sotheby’s, Fine American Furniture, Folk Art, Silver and China Trade Paintings including Property from the Estate of Esther Pace Kuna, New York, June 23, 1988, sale 5736, lot 445.) An early label on the chair states that it belonged to Rev. Thomas Potwine (1731–1802), who was born in Boston and moved to East Windsor, Connecticut. His grandfather was John Potwine (1668–1700), who immigrated to Boston in 1698, and his father was John Potwine (1698–1792), who was probably the chair’s first owner.

  • Figure 38
    Figure 38

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 50 1/2", W. 23 1/4", D. 17". (Courtesy, Peabody Historical Society and Museum; photo, Andrew Davis.) This chair belonged to Rev. Benjamin Prescott (1687–1777), the first pastor of South Church in Danvers (now Peabody), Massachusetts. The scrolled terminals of the arms and the feet are replaced. This chair is unique in that the original trapezoidal stitching in the seat is embellished with brass nails.

  • Figure 39
    Figure 39

    Detail of the stretchers of the armchair illustrated in fig. 38.

  • Figure 40
    Figure 40

    Side chair, probably Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 46 1/2", W. 18", D. 15". (Courtesy, Albany Institute of History and Art, gift of James Ten Eyck, 1908.1; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This chair descended through the Pierson family of Kingston, New York.

  • Figure 41
    Figure 41

    Detail of the original webbing and sackcloth under-upholstery of the side chair illustrated in fig. 40. The standard arrangement for webbing strips on side chairs applied by Boston and New York upholsterers was two strips front-to-back and one side-to-side. The trapezoidal-shaped stitching at the center of the seat is visible. Upholsterers would attach the webbing and then the sackcloth. The leather was roughly shaped to fit and then secured to the under-upholstery with waxed gut stitching. Grass was then stuffed in on the four sides and secured when the leather was nailed to the rails. The rough edges were concealed with trim strips of leather generally secured with double rows of decorative brass-headed nails on the front and sides, while the back edge was secured with wrought iron nails. The trim strip on the sides of this chair was secured along the top edge with brass-headed nails, but the bottom edge was secured with wrought tacks.

  • Figure 42
    Figure 42

    Detail showing the back of the crest of the side chairs illustrated in figs. 36 (left) and 40 (right). The back edges of the piercings are neatly chamfered, and the edges of the C-scrolls have a simple single chamfer at a 45 degree angle. While irregular now because of shrinkage, the leather pulled through the slot on fig. 40 would have originally been cut along a straight line.

  • Figure 43
    Figure 43

    Side chair, England, 1690–1710. Ash; original leather upholstery. H. 44 1/2", W. 19", D. 16". (Courtesy, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, 1954-990.) The cylindrical turning between the seat and the lower back rail is identical to that found on the later groups of early baroque Boston chairs.

  • Figure 44
    Figure 44

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 47 1/2", W. 18 1/2", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 45
    Figure 45

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 51", W. 24", D. 22". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 46
    Figure 46

    Table, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1720. Maple and white pine. H. 27 3/4", W. 37 3/4", D. 21 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The conical turning on the stretchers is nearly identical to that on the rear posts of group D chairs. The legs have turning identical to those on the arm supports of several of the leather-upholstered armchairs.

  • Figure 47
    Figure 47

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 48 1/2", W. 18 1/8", D. 14 1/2". (Courtesy, Wadsworth Atheneum, Wallace Nutting Collection, gift of J. Pierpont Morgan Jr., 1926.446; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This chair descended in the Pierson family of Kingston, New York, and was first illustrated in Wallace Nutting, Furniture of the Pilgrim Century, 1620–1720 (Boston: Marshall Jones Company, 1921), p. 221, with a later crest that has now been removed. A remnant is all that remains of the lower ball on the foot.

  • Figure 48
    Figure 48

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 47 1/2", W. 19", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 49
    Figure 49

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple. H. 48 1/2", W. 23", D. 17". (Courtesy, Art Institute of Chicago, Mr. and Mrs. William Y. Hutchinson Fund, 1989.57; photo, Art Resource, Inc.) The arms and feet are replaced; the arms would have resembled those on the armchair illustrated in fig. 45.

  • Figure 50
    Figure 50

    Side chair, New York City, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 47", W. 18 1/2", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 51
    Figure 51

    Side chair, New York City, 1705–1715. Maple and oak. H. 45 3/4", W. 18", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 52
    Figure 52

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1720. Maple and oak. H. 53 1/8", W. 22 3/4", D. 17 1/2". (Courtesy, Smithtown Historical Society, gift of Mrs. Norman Parke; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) Family tradition maintained that this chair belonged to Ebenezer Smith (1712–1747). His father, Richard Smith II (ca. 1645–1720), was the chair’s probable first owner (Dean Failey, Long Island Is My Nation: Decorative Arts & Craftsmen 1640–1830, 2nd edition [Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.: Society for the Preservation of Long Island Antiquities, 1998], no. 23. pp. 26–7).

  • Figure 53
    Figure 53

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1720. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 53 1/4", W. 22 7/8", D. 17". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 54
    Figure 54

    Side view of the armchair illustrated in fig. 53. The height and dramatic cant of the chair back would make it susceptible to falling backward if not for the rearward kick of the rear feet.

  • Figure 55
    Figure 55

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1720. Maple and oak. H. 47 1/2". (Courtesy, Freeman’s; photo, Thomas Clark.) The front stretcher is replaced. The original would have related to those on the chairs shown in figs. 52 and 53.

  • Figure 56
    Figure 56

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. H. 46 3/4", W. 18 1/2", D. 14 7/8". (Courtesy, Washington’s Headquarters State Historic Site, Newburgh, New York Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, WH.1971.641; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This chair is one of three donated by Enoch Carter to Washington’s Headquarters prior to 1858. The chairs descended through the Ver Planck (also Verplanck) family and were reputedly used as altar furniture at the Dutch Reformed Church, Fishkill, New York.

  • Figure 57
    Figure 57

    Detail of the back of the crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 56, showing the PVP brand. The back edges of the crest and the piercings are chamfered to lighten the crest visually when seen from the front.

  • Figure 58
    Figure 58

    Composite illustration showing the back of the lower stretcher of the group E side chair illustrated in fig. 56 (top) and group E side chair illustrated in fig. 69 (bottom). Boston chairmakers constructed their seating quickly and efficiently. As the saw kerfs visible here reveal, makers did not always plane the back surfaces of stretchers. The same is true of some crests.

  • Figure 59
    Figure 59

    Composite illustration showing the front turned feet of the group E side chair illustrated in fig. 56 (left) and group E side chair illustrated in fig. 69 (right). The baluster‑and-half-ball, or “double-ball,” foot was the standard for early eighteenth-century Boston chairmakers. Through centuries of use, many surviving chairs have lost the lower half‑ball if not their entire foot.

  • Figure 60
    Figure 60

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 50 1/2", W. 24 1/2", D. 23". (Courtesy, Wadsworth Atheneum, the Evelyn Bonar Storrs Trust Fund, 1994.4.1; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) While the chair’s original owner is unknown, it descended in the Schuyler and Church families of New York. The chair was purchased from a descendant of John Baker Church (1777–1818) and Angelica Schuyler (1756–1814). Angelica was the daughter of Gen. Philip Schuyler (1733–1804) and Catherine Van Rensselaer (1735–1803) of Albany. The feet and the proper right finial are replaced.

  • Figure 61
    Figure 61

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 52", W. 24 1/4", D. 21 1/4". (Courtesy, The Henry Ford, 30.557.64.) Henry Ford purchased the chair from Charles Woolsey Lyon of New York City in 1930. Lyon acquired the chair in 1901 from Mr. Stephen Schuyler of the Flats, Albany, New York. Stephen Schuyler stated that the chair originally belonged to Pieter Schuyler (1657–1724). The Flats is an area north of Albany along the Hudson River. The front stretcher is incorrectly replaced.

  • Figure 62
    Figure 62

    Nehemiah Partridge (1683–ca. 1737), Pieter Schuyler, Albany, New York, ca. 1718. Oil on canvas. 87 3/4" x 51". (Courtesy, New York State Museum.)    

  • Figure 63
    Figure 63

    General Philip Schuyler House, ca. 1690 with a ca. 1765 addition, Colonie Township, Albany County, New York. (Courtesy, Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, HABS no. NY-3102.) This house was destroyed by fire in 1962.

  • Figure 64
    Figure 64

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 52 5/8", W. 23 1/8", D. 17". (Courtesy, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, gift of Anne and Frederick Vogel III, 2016.538.) This chair is branded “W. MANCIUS” on the lower back rail. The feet are replaced.

  • Figure 65
    Figure 65

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. H. 49 3/4", W. 18 1/2", D. 14 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The lower back rail is branded “W. MANCIUS”. The feet are replaced.

  • Figure 66
    Figure 66

    Composite illustration showing the brands on back of the lower back rails of the armchair illustrated in fig. 64 (left) and the side chair illustrated in fig. 65 (right).

  • Figure 67
    Figure 67

    Rev. George Wilhelmus Mancius, attributed to Pieter Vanderlyn (ca.1687–1778), Kingston, New York, ca. 1735. Oil on canvas. Measurements not recorded. (Courtesy, First Reformed Protestant Dutch Church of Kingston, New York.)

  • Figure 68
    Figure 68

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 51 3/4", W. 23 1/4", D. 16 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This chair was found in Yonkers, New York. Upholstery evidence indicates that this chair’s trim strip was secured on the side seat rails with a top row of brass-headed nails and the bottom with wrought tacks.

  • Figure 69
    Figure 69

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. H. 49", W. 18", D. 15". (Courtesy, Washington’s Headquarters State Historic Site, Newburgh, New York Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, WH.1971.643; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) Four chairs from this set are known. According to Israel Sack, Inc., the chairs were purchased from descendants of the Van Rensselaer family.

  • Figure 70
    Figure 70

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 47", W. 18 1/8", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The feet are replaced.

  • Figure 71
    Figure 71

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 48", W. 18 1/2", D. 14 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Jim Wildeman.)

  • Figure 72
    Figure 72

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 48", W. 17 7/8", D. 14 5/8". (Courtesy, Metropolitan Museum of Art, bequest of Mrs. J. Insley Blair, 1951, 52.77.58; photo, image copyright © Metropolitan Museum of Art. Image source: Art Resource, Inc.)

  • Figure 73
    Figure 73

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 51 1/4", W. 23", D. 16 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The  upper portion of the crest rail is replaced.

  • Figure 74
    Figure 74

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 50 5/8", W. 23 1/4", D. 16 7/8". (Courtesy, Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, gift of Mr. and Mrs. Miodrag R. Blagojevich, 1976-431.)

  • Figure 75
    Figure 75

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 49 1/2", W. 23", D. 16 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 76
    Figure 76

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 45 3/8", W. 18", D. 15 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 77
    Figure 77

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 45 1/4", W. 18", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 78
    Figure 78

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 45 1/4", W. 18 1/2", D. 15 3/4". (Courtesy, Wadsworth Atheneum, Wallace Nutting Collection, gift of J. Pierpont Morgan Jr., 1926.440; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 79
    Figure 79

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 38 3/8", W. 17 3/4", D. 14 3/8". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 80
    Figure 80

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and oak. H. 38 1/4", W. 18", D. 15 1/8". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 81
    Figure 81

    Back stool, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1725. Maple. H. 44 3/4", W. 18 3/4", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The feet and upper portion of the back are replaced.

  • Figure 82
    Figure 82

    Back stool, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple. H. 48 1/4", W. 19 1/2", D. 15 1/8". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont, 1989.506; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The heels on this chair are quite pronounced and prevented the high-backed chair from toppling over.

  • Figure 83
    Figure 83

    Detail of the stretchers, legs, and double cyma-shaped front seat rail of the back stool illustrated in fig. 82. (Photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 84
    Figure 84

    Easy chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple. H. 48 1/8", W. 31 1/2", D. 35 1/2". (Courtesy, Philadelphia Museum of Art, 125th Anniversary Acquisition, gift of Anne H. and Frederick Vogel III, 1999.)

  • Figure 85
    Figure 85

    Couch, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple. Dimensions not recorded. (Richard Withington, Inc., Oliver E. Williams Collection, Pigeon Cove, Cape Ann, Massachusetts, July 27, 1966, p. 22.)

  • Figure 86
    Figure 86

    Couch, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple. H. 39 1/2", L. 61". (Courtesy, Bernard and S. Dean Levy, Inc.) This couch belonged to Rev. Daniel Shute (1722–1802) and his wife, Mary Cushing (1732–1756). Shute was the pastor of the Second Parish in Hingham (now Cohasset), Massachusetts, for nearly fifty‑six years.

  • Figure 87
    Figure 87

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1715. Maple and ash. H. 49", W. 18 3/4", D. 16 3/8". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This banister-back chair has a crest identical to those of the leather chairs illustrated in figs. 44 and 45.

  • Figure 88
    Figure 88

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 52 3/4", W. 23", D. 16". (Private collection; photo, Jim Wildeman.) The feet are replaced. This chair and the one shown in fig. 89 originally would have been used with a large pillow that would have filled the space between the back rail and the seat.

  • Figure 89
    Figure 89

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 52 5/8", W. 23 1/2", D. 16 5/8". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This is one of only two known examples of a Boston banister-back armchair with a carved crest rail and front stretcher. The other was offered by Roderic Blackburn but had replaced finials and feet.

  • Figure 90
    Figure 90

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 49 1/2", W. 17 1/2", D. 14". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) The finials and the upper portion of the crest rail are replaced.

  • Figure 91
    Figure 91

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 46 1/2", W. 18 1/4", D. 14 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 92
    Figure 92

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 47", W. 18 1/2", D. 14 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) This chair was embellished with gilt decoration in the late nineteenth century. This chair has lost a portion of its feet.

  • Figure 93
    Figure 93

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730. Maple and ash. H. 47 1/2". (Courtesy, Sotheby’s, Important Americana including Property from the Collection of Joan Oestreich Kend, New York, January 21, 2017, lot 4327.)

  • Figure 94
    Figure 94

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1730, Maple and ash. H. 48 1/8", W. 18 3/4", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Jon Lam.) This chair, like the examples illustrated in figs. 79 and 80, has its crest rail placed on top of the stiles rather than between them.

  • Figure 95
    Figure 95

    Armchair, probably London, 1705–1715. Walnut. Dimensions not recorded. (Courtesy, Victoria and Albert Museum, given by W. H. Hammond in memory of Lieut. R. M. Hammond, Circ. 525-1921.)
    The chair originally had a caned back and seat. The feet are replaced. The chairs in group E have arched crests and stretchers and turnings related to those on this chair. 

  • Figure 96
    Figure 96

    Side chair, probably London, 1705–1715. Woods and dimensions not recorded. (Photo, Symonds Collection, Decorative Arts Photographic Collection, Winterthur Museum.) This chair originally had a caned back. The double side stretchers belie its later date as indicated with its arched crest, simple conical stiles, and cylindrical turnings above the seat.

  • Figure 97
    Figure 97

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1705–1725. Maple. H. 50 3/4", W. 25 3/4", D. 27". (Chipstone Foundation; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 98
    Figure 98

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1725. Maple. H. 50 3/4", W. 17 1/2", D. 14 3/8". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 99
    Figure 99

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1725. Maple. Measurements not recorded. (Courtesy, Northeast Auctions, New Hampshire Weekend Auction, Portsmouth, New Hampshire, November 7, 2004, lot 723.) This chair has lost the upper portion of the carved crest, and the feet are replaced.

  • Figure 100
    Figure 100

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1725. Maple and birch. H. 55". (Courtesy, ©2005 Christie’s, Important American Furniture, Folk Art, Silver and Prints, New York, January 21, 2005, sale 1474, lot 544.)

  • Figure 101
    Figure 101

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1725. Maple. H. 48 3/4". (Courtesy, ©2005 Christie’s, Important American Furniture, Folk Art, Silver and Prints, New York, January 21, 2005, sale 1474, lot 545.)

  • Figure 102
    Figure 102

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1735. Maple. H. 45 1/4", W. 18", D. 14 1/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 103
    Figure 103

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1735. Maple. H. 45 1/4", W. 17 1/2", D. 14 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 104
    Figure 104

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1740. Maple. H. 50 3/4", W. 23 3/8", D. 16 3/8". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 105
    Figure 105

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1740. Maple. H. 45 1/2", W. 19", D. 18". (Chipstone Foundation; photo, Skinner, Inc., American Furniture & Decorative Arts, Boston, Massachusetts, February 18, 2007, sale 2349, lot 229.)

  • Figure 106
    Figure 106

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1740. Maple. H. 49 7/8", W. 24 1/4", D. 21". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont, 1954.528; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) This armchair descended in the Hancock family of Boston, Massachusetts. This chair is one of the earliest examples showing the placement of the medial stretchers forward.

  • Figure 107
    Figure 107

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1725–1745. Maple. H. 44 3/4", W. 23", D. 18 3/4". (Courtesy, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, gift of Mr. and Mrs. Henry Herbert Edes, 36.37.) This chair descended in the Edes family of Boston and South Dartmouth, Massachusetts.

  • Figure 108
    Figure 108

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1725–1730. Maple and oak. H. 48 1/2". (Courtesy, Skinner Inc., Personal Collection of Lewis Scranton, Killingsworth, Connecticut, May 21, 2016, sale 2897M, lot 303.) The feet are replaced. The splat directly relates to contemporaneous Chinese vases on stands.

  • Figure 109
    Figure 109

    Baluster vase, Qing Dynasty, Kangxi Period (1662–1722). (Courtesy, Sotheby’s Inc.)

  • Figure 110
    Figure 110

    Side chair, probably London, 1715–1725. Woods and dimensions not recorded. (Helen Churchill Candee, Jacobean Furniture and English Styles in Oak and Walnut [New York: Frederick A. Stokes Company, 1916], pl. 31.)

  • Figure 111
    Figure 111

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1745. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 45 1/4", W. 17 3/4", D. 18 1/8". (Courtesy, Wadsworth Atheneum, gift of James B. Cone, by exchange, 1982.160; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The applied carved front foot facings have been lost.

  • Figure 112
    Figure 112

    Armchair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1745. Maple and oak. H. 47 3/4", W. 22 3/4", D. 16 7/8". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont, 1958.556; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 113
    Figure 113

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and oak. H. 45 1/2", W. 17 1/2", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) The applied carved front foot facings have been lost.

  • Figure 114
    Figure 114

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and oak. H. 45 1/2", W. 17 1/2", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 115
    Figure 115

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and ash. H. 44 3/4", W. 18", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) The front scroll feet on cabriole legged chairs are not laminated because of the extra dimension of the leg stock necessary to produce the curvature.

  • Figure 116
    Figure 116

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and oak. H. 44 3/4", W. 19", D. 15 3/4". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 117
    Figure 117

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1728–1735. Maple and oak. H. 45 7/8", W. 19", D. 15 1/2". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 118
    Figure 118

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and oak. H. 44 3/4", W. 18 1/4", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.)

  • Figure 119
    Figure 119

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple. H. 44 1/4", W. 20", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) The applied carved front foot facings have been lost.

  • Figure 120
    Figure 120

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1750. Maple and ash. H. 45 3/4", W. 19", D. 14 1/2". (Private collection; photo, Andrew Davis.) A related upholstered side chair with a solid splat is illustrated in Joan Freund and Leigh Keno, “The Making and Marketing of Boston Seating Furniture in the Late Baroque Style,” in American Furniture, edited by Luke Beckerdite (Hanover, N.H.: University Press of New England for the Chipstone Foundation, 1998), fig. 8.

  • Figure 121
    Figure 121

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1720–1745. Maple and oak; original leather upholstery. H. 41 3/4", W. 19", D.14 3/8". (Courtesy, Newport Historical Society.) The original owner of this chair may have been William Ellery (1727–1820) of Newport, Rhode Island. William C. Cozzens (b. 1846) found it in the Ellery House, Thames Street, Newport, Rhode Island, and it was donated to the Newport Historical Society in 1855. The applied carved front foot facings have been lost.

  • Figure 122
    Figure 122

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1725–1750. Maple and ash. H. 44 3/4", W. 18", D. 15". (Private collection; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 123
    Figure 123

    Side chair, probably Boston, Massachusetts, 1710–1720. Maple. H. 52 1/8", W. 21 3/8", D. 22 1/4". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, bequest of H. F. du Pont, 1959.28.2; photo, Gavin Ashworth.)

  • Figure 124
    Figure 124

    Side chair, England, 1700–1710. Beech. Measurements not recorded. (Courtesy, Victoria and Albert Museum, London, W.36-1914.)

  • Figure 125
    Figure 125

    Side chair, Boston, Massachusetts, 1740–1770. Maple. H. 39 1/2", W. 22", D. 20 1/4". (Courtesy, Winterthur Museum, Museum Purchase with funds provided by Mr. and Mrs. George M. Kaufman, Mr. Martin E. Wunsch, and an anonymous donor, 1998.7; photo, Gavin Ashworth.) The trim strip of leather is applied with a double row of brass-headed nails just as chairs made in Boston were ornamented half a century earlier.

  • Figure 126
    Figure 126

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 2.

  • Figure 127
    Figure 127

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 25.

  • Figure 128
    Figure 128

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 25.

  • Figure 129
    Figure 129

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 28. 

  • Figure 130
    Figure 130

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 28.

  • Figure 131
    Figure 131

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 29.

  • Figure 132
    Figure 132

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 31.

  • Figure 133
    Figure 133

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 31.

  • Figure 134
    Figure 134

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 32.

  • Figure 135
    Figure 135

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 34.

  • Figure 136
    Figure 136

    Detail of the carved stretcher of armchair illustrated in fig. 34.

  • Figure 137
    Figure 137

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 36.

  • Figure 138
    Figure 138

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 36.

  • Figure 139
    Figure 139

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 40.

  • Figure 140
    Figure 140

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 40.

  • Figure 141
    Figure 141

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 44.

  • Figure 142
    Figure 142

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 44.

  • Figure 143
    Figure 143

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 45.

  • Figure 144
    Figure 144

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 45.

  • Figure 145
    Figure 145

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 50.

  • Figure 146
    Figure 146

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 50.

  • Figure 147
    Figure 147

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 52.

  • Figure 148
    Figure 148

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 52.

  • Figure 149
    Figure 149

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 53.

  • Figure 150
    Figure 150

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 53.

  • Figure 151
    Figure 151

    Detail of the carved crest of the side chair illustrated in fig. 56.

  • Figure 152
    Figure 152

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 56.

  • Figure 153
    Figure 153

    Detail of the carved crest of the armchair illustrated in fig. 60.

  • Figure 154
    Figure 154

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 60.

  • Figure 155
    Figure 155

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 64.

  • Figure 156
    Figure 156

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 65.

  • Figure 157
    Figure 157

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 65.

  • Figure 158
    Figure 158

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 68.

  • Figure 159
    Figure 159

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 68.

  • Figure 160
    Figure 160

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 69.

  • Figure 161
    Figure 161

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 69.

  • Figure 162
    Figure 162

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 70.

  • Figure 163
    Figure 163

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 70.

  • Figure 164
    Figure 164

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 71.

  • Figure 165
    Figure 165

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 71.

  • Figure 166
    Figure 166

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 72.

  • Figure 167
    Figure 167

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 79.

  • Figure 168
    Figure 168

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 80.

  • Figure 169
    Figure 169

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 88.

  • Figure 170
    Figure 170

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 89.

  • Figure 171
    Figure 171

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 89.

  • Figure 172
    Figure 172

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 90.

  • Figure 173
    Figure 173

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 91.

  • Figure 174
    Figure 174

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 92.

  • Figure 175
    Figure 175

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 94.

  • Figure 176
    Figure 176

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 94.

  • Figure 177
    Figure 177

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 97.

  • Figure 178
    Figure 178

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the side chair illustrated in fig. 98.

  • Figure 179
    Figure 179

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the side chair illustrated in fig. 98.

  • Figure 180
    Figure 180

    Detail of the carved stretcher of the armchair illustrated in fig. 99.

  • Figure 181
    Figure 181

    Detail of the carved crest rail of the armchair illustrated in fig. 106.